The oral argument of the day is from the Federal Circuit’s decision in In re Tropp, decided this past December. The Federal Circuit panel was critical of the PTAB for not writing a clear opinion — so unclear that remand was necessary.
Interestingly, Judge Moore’s remarks during the oral argument seem much more critical of the Board than any comment that made its way into the decision that she authored for the court.
You can listen to one strong remark below:
You can listen to the entire oral argument here:
You can read the court’s opinion here: [Link].